Home > Uncategorized > Is it possible to prove a research hypothesis?

Is it possible to prove a research hypothesis?

Hello! Back again for week 3! (isn’t the year just flying by!).
We’ve been given a wild card this week! I got to choose what I was going to discuss all by myself (well..I kinda choose it off a list of possible blog topics, but we won’t worry about that).

So, I have decided to tell you all about research hypothesis.

I’m sure the majority of you are aware what a research hypothesis is, but for those who don’t allow me to explain.

There are a few definitions of ‘research hypothesis’, but generally, this one seems good enough to illustrate my point:  ‘A proposition about the nature of the world that makes predictions about the results of an experiment.’  (Taken from: www.sinauer.com/fmri2e/html/glossary.html ).   So, I think that the key word here is ‘predictions’.  You’re making a prediction about what you think will happen when you carry out your research.

OK…an example.  Imagine that you want to research what colour swans are.  Now, in your life, I’m sure that most, if not all, of you have only ever come across white swans and therefore may think that all swans are white.  So, you make your research hypothesis that all swans are white.  You go out, scour several places in search of swans, and you keep count of how many different coloured swans you find.  At the end of your research, you take a look at your data, and sure enough all the swans you saw were white.  Great, your research hypothesis was right, right?

Nope…you can’t say unequivocally that all swans are white, because you didn’t see all the swans in the world. Would you ever be able to be absolutely sure that you have seen all the swans in the world?  Could you ever prove, for sure that your research hypothesis is correct?  I’m afraid not.  It’s never possible to prove a research hypothesis, but only to collect a lot of data that can strongly support it.

You can, however, disprove a research hypothesis.  Thinking about the swans again, you could have spent years and years finding all the swans you could. Searching high and low in all the parks and ponds you could find, and STILL, you could have only found white swans!  Someone could come along, and in an instant ruin your years of work by finding a black swan.  Well, there we go….your research hypothesis was that all swans are white. You have tons and tons of data showing that swans are white, and this person goes and finds a black swan!! So, if this black swan exists, ALL swans can’t be white. Which means, unfortunately, your research hypothesis is wrong (and you’ve wasted years of your life looking at swans…good job this is hypothetical).

As a side note, I hope that nobody did actually do this research, because black swans have been discovered in Australia:

 

Not that I stole the swan story from a famous example or anything…but there is a book by Nassim Nicholas Taleb, called ‘The black swan: the impact of the highly improbable’ which discusses this in detail.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Black-Swan-Impact-Highly-Improbable/dp/0141034599

The idea of a black swan may have been highly improbable, but it’s never impossible (clearly as my picture above demonstrates).  You can never say that a research hypothesis has been proven. Even if all the data in the world strongly supports it, that only makes it highly probable.  We can never say that it is never impossible to find proof of the opposite.

 

To finish off, here’s a video of Nassim himself giving a talk on ‘black swans’.  (I personally think I explained it better 😉  but there you go).

 

 

 

 

Thanks for coming again, next week I have another wild card…so who knows what’s in store for you!

Au revoir.

Advertisements
Categories: Uncategorized
  1. October 14, 2011 at 3:35 pm

    I was so convinced swans were all white when I was younger. In a funny way, maybe a research hypothesis is almost a guide for life when it comes to exploration and learning. The basic message being, nothing is impossible. I enjoy the way you write, I certainly don’t miss anything thanks to your breakdown of the topic and examples that we can all relate to. Would you agree that a research hypothesis can be proven if the study area is specific enough, is there any situation in which we can fully prove a theory? Final note, swans scare the hell out of me and are mean, big and ridiculously dangerous

    • October 18, 2011 at 1:05 pm

      I don’t want this comment marked or anything….but swans scare me too :p

  2. October 14, 2011 at 4:04 pm

    I think that there needs to be some focus here on smaller groups and how a research hypothesis could be proved if this was the case. Using the example of psychology uni students, at Bangor uni in their first year, this is quite a small group that if you were to formulate a research hypothesis about, it would most likely be proven. It is an easily accessible group who can be accessed in bulk (as was the case with the 9am test session today) However you a correct that most of the time, it is quite impossible to prove a research hypothesis, as the case would be with the swans.

    • October 18, 2011 at 1:10 pm

      If you were testing a smaller group, say sticking with your example of Bangor university first year students, then I still don’t believe it would be possible to PROVE your research hypothesis. Say, for example, you were testing to see whether first year students who attended more lectures got better results on exams. OK, so I’m guessing your research hypothesis would be that students who attended more lectures would get better results on exams. I’m sure your results would support your research hypothesis, but does it prove it? How can you say for 100% definite that those students got better results because they went to more lectures? Maybe they’re just naturally smarter. Maybe naturally smarter people are more inclined to go to more lectures? They were going to do better anyway because they are naturally smarter, or better at revising, or better at sitting exams? You can’t say for sure that your research hypothesis has been PROVEN!

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: